I tried to compute the CFR the same way Crawford does. Its almost impossible to salvage Crawfords argument. All physician phone calls or video visits cost $115, cash only. The topic here is Steve Kirsch's bogus claim that COVID vaccines shorten the life expectancy of people who are enrolled in Medicare. Millions in claimed donations from Silicon Valley's elite. Im not interested in doing that. Not just a few pilots. 01 Aug 2000. If we cherry-pick these reports to scare people, we should also share post-vaccination reports claiming nose bleeds, anal leakages, and the unbelievable swelling of the male reproductive apparatus. Experiments that should yield either result A or B show us C, instead. Steve offered a million dollars to prove that there had been less than 500 vaccine deaths in the US. Right after Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin collapsed from a cardiac arrest after a tackle and was resuscitated on the field, antivaxxers immediately pounced, blaming COVID-19 vaccines even as CPR . New York had a big wave of covid deaths in spring 2020, but California was spared. More than a year after. He wants to be recognized for it. And its the same thing with every category. The change is important, because it proves what Steve actually thinks. The double-blind randomized trial was done in 2021. Longer-term follow-up data was not available. How does this compare to the theoretical picture? Studying excess deaths is important, because the number of covid deaths doesnt line up with the number of excess deaths in America. Elon Musk builds rockets but doesnt fly on them. October 2022 is late for COVID. 9 hr ago. The government message is not as interesting to many people. A few countries that work are Australia, New Zealand, Norway, Denmark, and South Korea. But kids are indestructible so a 30% injury rate in kids translates into a higher rate for adults. Second, while the spike protein gets assembled into new viral particles during an actual infection, no viral particles are generated from being vaccinated. Both concluded that, while it was possible the vaccine had somehow awakened the varicella-zoster virus in these people, this cause-and-effect link could not be established. But you cant hide these things for long. On page 43 of his document, Steve claims there are 771,066 excess deaths in America and 600,000 covid deaths. Are covid deaths undercounted? Steve said he wouldnt debate unless he could pick the judges, and he nominated 2 judges that already agreed with him. However, the study relied upon patient self-report and self-measurement of symptoms. A simple analysis shows that it is likely that over 150,000 Americans have been killed by the current COVID vaccines as of Aug 28, 2021. First, lets ask: what do people do when they get so rich that they dont need more money? Apple Podcasts Preview. But the vaccine is supposed to be safe. Nobody caught it. Uh oh. Every virus, without exception, should be treated early. Longer-term follow-up data was not available. People start dying before tests get rolled out. The point of this graph is to show that the COVID outbreak exacerbated the slope since you are seeing effects of seasonality PLUS the waning part of a COVID outbreak. The premise made sense: Most experts were predicting vaccines would take years, while finding helpful drugs with known safety profiles could shortcut the approval process. But while this effort was praiseworthy, Kirschs predilection for oversimplifying and exaggerating led him to mislead. A 63-year-old engineer who loves "solving hard problems," Kirsch started talking to scientists and studying the coronavirus that has infected 22.2 million people and killed 783,525 worldwide,. Scientists and clinicians are studying a host of drugs and therapeutics to create a new line of defence against the virus but clinical trials are yet to lead to conclusive evidence on any of these. A guy like Mathew Crawford probably cant hack it in terms of discovering new covid drugs or treatments, but he can compete at being one of the best guys to lie about covid vaccines. Steve also asked Dr Angela Rasmussen if she would debate him for a million dollars. World leaders have promised nothing for outpatient trials, and the short-term way to attack a virus is to discover a drug or drugs that are already on the shelf today.. The ethical problem here is the misleading claims," Joffe said via email. Confidence in the CDC and the medical community should hit rock bottom after it is revealed how extensive the damage caused by these vaccines is. Steve tries to rescue this argument by saying that maybe the vaccine only kills elderly people and the vaccine deaths happened back in December and January, when the oldest people were getting the shots. For more information about the change, see Myocarditis: Once Rare, Now Common. The truth is, youre just a mark for these 2 grifters. I have been vaccinated and my entire family has beenvaccinated. I think the fentanyl deaths are mostly an issue of the drugs being unpredictably strong, not so much deaths of despair. More recently, someone tried to take Steve up on a million dollar bet debating covid vaccines. The. We look at countries and states where the pandemic is under control. I told him it was because there are too many pilots that would otherwise have failed the exam, and that I believe this is because of the jabs. Crawford pretends hes shown that the vaccine is deadly. All the sudden deaths started post-vaccine. Kirsch told MedPage Today that his efforts are purely humanitarian -- almost no one was supporting this kind of research, so he stepped up to the plate. Alex Berenson is making over $700,000 per year on substack. Entries for each day are listed alphabetically by surname. Heres an example of a VAERS report an 89 year old woman who died 5 days after vaccination: Write-up: Resident in our long term care facility who received first dose of Moderna COVID-19 Vaccine on 12/22/2020, only documented side effect was mild fatigue after receiving. I use quotes because he didnt actually interact with a single one of the charts, graphs, or arguments I laid out. All rights reserved. But, for some reason, those countries cant all just come together and hide 100% of the evidence. It is tricky work, but you know what is easier? The problem with Steves claim is that you need some place to hide all those bodies. One theory is that were not diagnosing every case of covid. As I learn more, I will refine the estimate. European countries had a CFR spike because every country in Europe had a covid spike during the winter. But Steve thinks that people are just failing to file reports. Our bodies do not make the coronavirus; they simply make the spike protein, and that protein becomes stuck inside the membrane of the cell that makes it. Copyright HT Digital Streams Ltd. All rights reserved. Bezos flew to space in his own rocket. Make a donation - COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund, For Web3 Collectors, Neal Stephensons 1-Of-1 NFT Is The Ultimate Metaverse Artifact With Bespoke Utility, Thinking Like A Magician Will Help You Imagine Branded Experiences, CMOs Reconsider Your Hybrid Communications Strategy, Rhuigi Villaseor Kept His Foot On The Gas. An off-patent drug that anyone can manufacture? There has not been a good randomized trial for early treatment with Camostat. On his blog, Kirsch went farther and has described fluvoxamine as "a small pill that transforms this destructive virus into a mild-mannered common cold." Murders went up by about 5,000 in 2020. Steve Kirsch background. Suicides actually went down in 2020. So 7M Americans now have hearts damaged by the COVID vaccine. Data does not show Covid-19 vaccines are linked to more heart attacks. The post provides a type of treatment algorithm that lists 19 different drugs. Cardiologist Thomas Levy is appalled at this change: We discuss his article Myocarditis: Once Rare, Now Common. Heres a graph of heart disease deaths in the US by week: The heart disease deaths spike at the same time as covid deaths spike, in spring 2020 and then again in winter. Dr. Bret Weinstein is an evolutionary biologist. Kirsch is a . The organization supports grantees through funding, improving study protocols, advertising trials through op-eds, newspaper and TV interviews, and finding ways to manufacture drugs faster and at lower cost. This virus causes chickenpox when were young. The United Kingdom's Office for National Statistics (ONS) has confirmed that the fully vaccinated population accounted for 92 percent of the Wuhan coronavirus (COVID-19) deaths in 2022.. ONS recently published the dataset on deaths by vaccination status in the country from April 1, 2021 up to the end of December 2022. nose bleeds, anal leakages, and the unbelievable swelling of the male reproductive apparatus, one in three people in the US will develop shingles, making unsupported claims during the pandemic, freeze the spike protein in the shape it has before unlocking the door to our cells, that protein becomes stuck inside the membrane of the cell that makes it, all 12 members of the scientific advisory board of his COVID-19 company to resign, declined a request for its emergency use authorization, what Steve Kirsch did back in December 2020, Kirsch pre-emptively accuses Obama and his friends, shouts at reporters and sends them emails in all caps, One of Last Centurys Most Influential Social Science Studies Is Pretty Bad. The UK is an island that had a bad covid outbreak. Europe would have to be mislabeling vaccine deaths as covid deaths, as well, so its more like 40 countries in on the plot. Author: KSDK Staff The fact that the FAA *quietly* changed the EKG parameters for pilots suggests that the vaccine is causing a huge number of pilots to fail their screening. He had no knowledge of it. "People have accused me of doing it out of my own self-interest. He says that Facebook took down one of his posts announcing his appearance on 60 Minutes. Not so much. Shingles is caused by the awakening of a dormant virus, varicella-zoster, in the human body. Of the current list of top paid political newsletters on Substack, former Times writer Alex Berenson and tech entrepreneur Steve Kirsch come in at sixth and nineteenth respectively, both known. If they work, he could prove it and save thousands, maybe millions of lives. Fraudulent and mediocre studies swayed the minds of people inclined to believe in large pharmaceutical conspiracy theories. That is why there are no before/after studies in the US. Fortunately it was at that point that I-- read in the New York Times, of all places, about the COVID Early Treatment Fund. More than a year after Covid-19 turned into a pandemic, there are few therapies that have proven to work. And to spend more on drug trials to prove which drugs work. There has been at least one case report of acute fluvoxamine toxicity and death. Crawford claims that the covid case fatality rate (CFR) went up in Europe, right around when vaccinations began: CFR is defined as covid deaths divided by covid cases. At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, Steve Kirsch created the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF) to finance trials of off-patent drugs in an attempt to find a potent treatment that had been staring us in the face. Theres a clearer signal but its still pretty noisy: To double check, I pulled up the same same graph on OurWorldInData, they use a slightly different time lag between cases and deaths (10 days instead of 18), but its about the same shape as mine. Steves friends didnt even agree with each other about covid, they just made 3 hours of noise. A central lesson we scientists learn in university is that science is complicated. Youd have to look carefully to prove it. Kirsch, like so many COVID misinformers, would grab hold of the free speech torch and try to convince his followers that the only way to settle the issue would be to debate it publicly. Its true on every island that avoided covid. And, of course, Steve never paid. The FDA doesnt approve drugs because theyre popular on social media. Get yourself a copy of. Add up all those categories and were at 91,000 excess deaths, with 59,000 that still need to be explained. Im pretty sure they wont tell me, so Ill speculate: its because they didnt want anyone to know. It was done after the vaccine rollout. Media coverage of Kirschs descent into anti-vaccine rhetoric portrays an iconoclastic man who shouts at reporters and sends them emails in all caps. The mRNA vaccines give some young men myocarditis after the 2nd shot. Ill take an educated guess as to why they did that. You have to read the terms and conditions to understand. The vaccine creates far more injury to the heart than COVID (which creates NO added risk per this large-scale Israeli study of 196,992 unvaccinated adults after Covid infection). The fund is managed by Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors, which will disburse grants that are recommended in coordination with research being undertaken by CETFs Scientific Advisory Board. Which is what Steve Kirsch did back in December 2020. Then Crawford makes the assumption that the CFR went up because vaccine deaths got smuggled in to the covid death numbers, while cases stayed the same. Or 1,000 people. Another anti-vaxxer (Igor Chudov) wrote to tell me that he likes getting followers and he likes making contributions. But there is an ethical problem here, according to Steven Joffe, MD, MPH, chief of medical ethics at the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine. We currently have almost 8,000 deaths reported. Veronica Hackethal, MD, MSc, Enterprise & Investigative Writer, MedPage Today Unintentional injuries went up by 19,000. People like solving puzzles. Follow. Anecdotally, cardiologists only started to notice the damage post-vaccine. Steve thinks otherwise. The biggest donors have been the Skoll Foundation ($1 million) and the Flu Lab ($1.3 million), according to an email from Kirsch. Before becoming a full-time telemedicine doctor, Haider worked as a hospitalist for about 10 years. Like those who champion ivermectin, Kirsch argues that time is of the essence in the pandemic, and patients shouldn't have to wait until a phase III trial proves whether fluvoxamine works or not. To former President Obama, its $1 million to join him in a debate, for which Kirsch pre-emptively accuses Obama and his friends of being misinformation spreaders. It just shows that claims like 150,000 vaccine deaths in the US are absurd. Those countries have nowhere to hide vaccine deaths. Don't forget to protect yourself, and your family, by vaccinating against COVID-19! Also, if you are a paid subscriber, youll be able to view the reader comments which are as valuable as the method. I think thats referring to drug overdoses. We count the hospitalizations and deaths better, that ratio seems to be more stable. Steve originally claimed that there were 25,000 vaccine deaths, and they were hidden in the CDCs unclassified deaths category (R00-R99 deaths). Decoding the microbial angle to health and the microbial world. Its eye opening. Fact check: False claim that Truth Social will charge users $4.99 per week. When approached by MedPage Today, Upsher Smith declined to comment. The quality of medical care declines, and people are more likely to die or heart disease or diabetes. It would be hard to disentangle deaths from covid and from the vaccine. Covid is a clotting disease, so mild cases are causing some people to die of heart attacks or strokes. STEVE KIRSCH (GUEST): They told -- the agencies, the FDA, the CDC, the NIH said that these vaccines were safe and effective. I am reminded of the old saying warning people against playing chess with pigeons. Im not sure, I havent looked that carefully or checked this since August. We found a preexisting drug that worked to keep my cancer at bay. If it was due to COVID, it would have happened well before now. https://ad.style/ Guest Post by Margaret Anna Alice. Our work in funding early treatments for COVID was featured on60 Mi nut es. So, Steve has a huge brain. One of those telemedicine doctors is Syed Haider, MBBS, who uses a Texas telephone number but says he is currently located in North Carolina. Looking for COVID-19 'Miracle Drugs'? Theyve left just enough bread crumbs that only this one scrappy substack blogger can figure it out. Recently, another old drug called fluvoxamine has come onto the scene. Those were not all vaccine deaths, because we only started vaccinating people on December 14th. But the FDA described the statements as "not based in science," and medical experts say the comments are . And Steves project didnt even fund the large trials that proved fluvoxamine successful, that was done by two other charities (the Rainwater Foundation and Fast Grants). A lot of pilots and a lot of damage. The p-value was <.01, i.e., they didnt just get lucky.. Its true in Scandinavia. Any guesses?? Steve Kirsch a mega donor for the Democratic Party Who has donated over $20 million to the Democrats will not give the Democrats one more penny. They widened it by a lot. For some men, the ultimate status game is saving the world. According to its founder, serial tech entrepreneur Steve Kirsch, CETF was started in April 2020 in order to fund. In April 2020, Kirsch founded the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF) to fund research into off-label treatments for COVID-19 among drugs already having FDA approval for other diseases, donating $1 million himself and also fundraising from others. The study included 113 workers at a California racetrack who tested positive for COVID-19 and were offered fluvoxamine. Others are investigational and only available in clinical trials. And this one, in particular, is devastating. Its totally possible that the covid vaccines have some dangerous side effects. Crawford thinks the vaccine deaths were smuggled into the data as covid deaths. Gates had some puzzling connection to Jeffrey Epstein. I didn't have to get an EKG this time, but I do have to once a year (everyone 45 and over, I think). We should study which vaccines are safest, whether teenage boys should get one shot or two, things like that. In that same IEEE Spectrum story about his then-new startup, Propel Software, he said he felt successful, but not famous. It's a general-purpose solution that also may reduce your risk of getting other viral and bacterial infections as well. This is a tacit admission of a huge problem. Generic fluvoxamine continues to be available in the U.S. The only major source of excess deaths thats unrelated is fentanyl overdoses. Explanation: The FDA explains that its statements are not based on science. In a Twitter post, he has offered $1 million to anyone who can identify a confounder that better explains these results (the money will be donated to the winner's medical research cause of choice, he said). "Most people with early COVID get better on their own, so you can't say that a drug is effective until you've shown it's better than placebo, or some other comparison, in a controlled trial," said Joffe. Steve admitted he was wrong, and promised to look into it more and fix his statements. How did he know this? MedPage Today explores how the old antidepressant has made its way to the COVID spotlight. Why is that? This argument was repeatedly discredited by myself, by Avi Bitterman, by @PiercedGeek. Steve Kirsch is a serial entrepreneur who, at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, had a good idea. How antivaxxers laid the groundwork to blame COVID-19 vaccines for Damar Hamlin's cardiac arrest. Rarer categories of deaths arent listed in that table. Individual studies are flawed, and our understanding of a problem is achieved by collating these puzzle pieces to the best of our ability and interpreting the emerging picture in a way that, we hope, minimizes our biases. A systematic review of published cases of shingles following (though not necessarily caused by) COVID vaccination identified 54 cases. Here are alzheimers disease deaths in CA (left) and NY (right): Here are diabetes deaths in CA (left) and NY (right): I have 2 theories for whats going on. I was tipped off about this story by Josh Yoder at US Freedom Flyers. Kirsch twisted Morris answer of Who knows, but not 150K, and not zero, into the headline, BOMBSHELL: Top biostats professor admits we have NO CLUE # of people KILLED by COVID vaccines, in an email he sent to journalists. They dont tend to line up with vaccination rates anywhere. Vaccines are the leading causes of coincidences it seems. Hes so confident in these two arguments that hes offered a million dollars to anyone who can prove these arguments wrong. That test is the gold-standard for cardiac injury. But his estimate of the number of vaccine deaths in America is very far from the truth, so I would suggest you be very cautious in believing any other claims he makes. Edited excerpts: In your advocacy, you focus on early treatment of Covid-19. There are 5 other drugs listed on the page. Maybe a lot of stuff. On the other hand, finding a country without excess deaths does prove the vaccine is safe if the vaccine is deadly, it has to be deadly everywhere. - He regularly exaggerates scientific findings and twists them to support his narrative that the COVID-19 vaccines are deadly and that off-patent drugs like ivermectin and fluvoxamine are highly effective against COVID-19. Finding a few countries where there were deaths after vaccines doesnt actually prove anything if there are excess deaths, it could also be covid. A clinical trial has demonstrated that the likelihood of hospitalisation was significantly reduced for patients with mild COVID-19 when given fluvoxamine. As a thank you to all my paid subscribers, Im going to remind you again what it is (Ive already written about it in the past, but Im going to add some more details). If the vaccines were as deadly as Steve thinks, youd expect a big 20% spike in excess mortality, while they were rolled out: There is no sign of a 20% increase. Computer centers were intimidating places in 1969. For his theory to be true, those 9 (mostly island) countries Ive pointed to must be lying and hiding their vaccine deaths. They can make changes every month. It doesnt look like thats happening in the US, I have not yet checked across Europe. If there were 150,000 vaccine deaths, youd think there would be 150,000 VAERS reports. In a 2008 blog post, Kirsch reminisced about urging people not to vote for Bush in 2000: He would be a disaster as President, Kirsch wrote, since he had a track record of ignoring facts, ignoring science, and twisting the facts to support his misguided beliefs., Take-home message: Over the course of his career, hehas founded more than seven companies, including Propel Software, Mouse Systems Corporation, Frame Technology Corporation, and Infoseek all dedicated to improving computer software and tech. To win the money, you dont even have to win the debate, you just have to try. "The L.A. Times did a piece, 60 Minutes followed, and now there's some attention," he told MedPage Today via email. The organization is also raising funds to support COVID-related trials of remdesivir, a broad-spectrum antiviral developed by Gilead Sciences, and Toyama Chemical's favipiravir, an antiviral medication currently used to treat influenza in Japan. Tag: Steve Kirsch Letter to the Stanford Daily. Kirsch also says that the online open publication platform Medium has deleted the last six years' worth of his content.