But the main reason for Millennium Bear being worth hundreds of dollars is actually because of the multiple spelling mistakes that can be found on its tush tag. 2000 TY ORIGINAL Political Lefty The Donkey Beanie Baby FREE SHIPPING, 1996 Lefty The Donkey and Righty The Elephant Ty beanie babies-New, TY Beanie Baby - LEFTY 2000 the Donkey (6 inch), Ty Beanie Babies 2000 LEFTY The Donkey Mint with Tag Free Shipping, Ty Beanie Baby LEFTY the Donkey Grey with American Flag 4 Gen Swing 3 Gen Tush, TY BEANIE BABIES : LEFTY THE DONKEY STILL SEALED, Ty Beanie Babies Lefty the Donkey 2000 and Righty the Elephant 2000, Lefty the Donkey TY Beanie Baby McDonalds w/ Errors, Lefty the Donkey and Righty The Elephant Beanie Babies 2000 w/ Tag Errors, Righty the Elephant and Lefty the Donkey beanie babies, Ty Beanie Babies Lefty the Donkey and Libearty the Bear Lot (RARE COLLECTIBLES), Lefty The Donkey Beanie Babies Plush Toy McDonalds Democrat - Ty American Trio. Lefty was one of two political Beanie Babies released for a Presidential election. Powered by Beanie Babies Price Guide . Ending Mar 7 at 1:15PM PST 8d 14h. This Thanksgiving Day favorite is worth about $7,000 if it wasnt thrown around the family dinner table around all mammas delicious dressing and mashed potatoes. 20 Most Valuable Beanie Babies - Money Inc 2023 beaniepedia.com. RARE TY Lefty 2000 Beanie Baby With Errors Political Donkey ,
or Best Offer. A pristine condition Humphrey the Camel can quickly go for $1,200 if it has clean tags and the sought-after leg defect. Provided you have the magenta-colored Patti, and its in mint condition (including tags), its value could be as high as $6,000. Captcha failed to load. Millenium vs Millennium Ty Beanie Baby - Variations and Values Recent Articles. The Version table provides details related to the release that this issue/RFE will be addressed. TY Beanie Baby Lefty Righty 2000 Esel Elefant Sterne und Streifen USA 4 But one complete set of 2014 Teenie Beanie Baby Boos from McDonald's is going for $850 on eBay, so you never know. I have Righty and Lefty beanie babies. How do I know their There is a TON of misinformation about Beanie Babies prices online. The sale listing includes newspaper articles of Clinton signing the toys.
BellasBraids. The first generation of the PVC pellet-filled stuffed toys remains one of the most valuable even almost three decades later. medianet_height = "280"; 2007 is the date on the tag. How do you know? Dec 27, 2021 4. Cubbie and Curly - $5,000. Two bears Cubbie and Both Lefty and Righty were the first two Beanie Babies sharing a poem. Good news! Although there are only two versions of these Beanie Babies, various tag errors will ring in dollars. Both of these plush toys are considered to be extremely rare and thus valuable. Youll see ad results based on factors like relevancy, and the amount sellers pay per click. 15-inch Peace bear and 9-inch Peace, Ringo and Bones - $159,000. . (30% off), Sale Price $9.00 The fuchsia toy has sold for around $12,000 in multiple eBay auctions, making it one of the more valuable items on this list. (function(w,d,t,r,u){var f,n,i;w[u]=w[u]||[],f=function(){var o={ti:"138000847"};o.q=w[u],w[u]=new UET(o),w[u].push("pageLoad")},n=d.createElement(t),n.src=r,n.async=1,n.onload=n.onreadystatechange=function(){var s=this.readyState;s&&s!=="loaded"&&s!=="complete"||(f(),n.onload=n.onreadystatechange=null)},i=d.getElementsByTagName(t)[0],i.parentNode.insertBefore(n,i)})(window,document,"script","//bat.bing.com/bat.js","uetq"); Below are some final sale prices in 2023 for Beanie Babies listed for sale online. You've already signed up for some newsletters, but you haven't confirmed your address. Tabasco was solid red except for some facial features, whereas, Snort had white markings on his hooves. In the article below, you can find out how much beanie babies are worth in 2022. Piccadilly was supposed to bring the cute back to clowns; however, kids seem to either love it or hate it. . Where to Sell Your Beanie Babies(Tips and ideas). -$7Tangles $8 - See GuideTank -$5Tasha -$30Tasty -$4Taz -$13Teddy -See GuideTed-e -$3Teegra -$12Tender -$8Tennessee -$8Texas -$5Texas Bluebonnet -$5Texas Rangers -$5Thank You -$5Thankful -$15The Beginning -$3The End $3 - See GuideTheodore -$25Thistle -$6Thomas -$5Thumper -$4Thunderbolt -$10Tibby -$7Ticklish -$10Tidings -$4Tiger -$3Tigger -$5Tiggs -$5Tiki -$15Timbers -$10Tinsel -$4Tiny -$3Tiny Tim -$4Tipsy -$5Tiptoe $2 - See GuideTitan -$10To Brighten -$10Toast -$6Toboggan -$3Tolee -$3TOM-e -$5Tommy -$3Tony Stewart #20 -$3Toodee -$10, Tooter $3 - See GuideToothy -$7Tootoot -$4Topper -$15Topspin -$4Tornado -$10Toronto -$3Tortuga -$5Tour Teddy -$4Tracker -$4Tracks $9 - See GuideTradee -$4Trap (1st Generation)Trap (2nd Generation) $55Trap (3rd Generation) $25Treator -$7Treats -$10Treehouse -$10Tremble -$5Trick R. Treat -$5Tricks $3 - See GuideTrickster -$3Tricky -$4Trident -$7Trimmings -$5TRUE -$4Truly -$4Trumpet $4 - See GuideTubbo -$6Tuck -$20Tucker -$6Tuffy -$2Tumba -$16Tunnels -$5Turk-e $10 - See GuideTusk -$4Tux -$4Tux Dog -$20Tweety -$25Twigs -$3Twilight -$5Twilight Sparkle -$5Twirls -$5Twirly -$5Twisty -$5Twitch -$8Twitterbug -$3Ty 2K $7 - See GuideTyrone -$15, Uncle Sam -$3Union -$4Uniqua -$10Unity -$3USA -$3, Valentina See GuideValentine -$4Valentino See GuideValley -$3Valor -$4Vanda -$3Vanish -$10Vegas -$3Veggies -$5Velvet -$3Victory -$1Villager -$4Vines -$10Violetta -$8Virunga -$3Viva Las Beanies -$10Volley -$4, Waddle -$3Wailea -$4Walden -$5Wales -$7Walker -$4Wallace -$3Washington -$3Wattlie -$3Waves $5 - See GuideWeaver -$3Webley -$3We Do -$20Weenie -$3Whiffles -$8Whiskers -$3Whisper -$3White -$3White Softbank -$100Whittle -$3Whopper -$4Widget -$4, Wiggly $3 - See GuideWiggy -$4Wilbur -$20William -$3Willoughby -$6Winksy -$4Winnie the Pooh -$5Winstar -$8Wirabear -$3Wisconsin -$4Wise $5 - See GuideWiser $3 - See GuideWisest -$3Wish -$3Witchy -$5Wonton -$15Woodstock -$10Woody -$3Woolins -$5Woolsy -$5Wrinkles -$3, Y Ddraig Goch -$20Yam Yam -$3Yapper -$5Yikes -$5Yokohama -$4Yodel -$5You Did It -$5Your Teddy Bear Elvis -$20Youre A Sweetie -$3Youre Special -$3Yours Truly $3 - See GuideYule -$2Yummy -$3, Zero -$3Zeus -$5Ziggy -$3Zip -See GuideZoom -$3Zoomer -$3Zuma -$5. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The first-generation beanie babies gathered the most interest, and collectors still value them today. Beckys True Blue Beans is one that is used a lot. Frequently the historical providence of specific Beanie Babies could send its value through the roof. Reply. Know Your Beanie Babies. Yet another sold for $14,800 in August 2020. Fill out the requested information.
HAPPY THE HIPPO - There is a gray version of Happy that is older. Right now, the rare 2000 autographed version of Lefty the Donkey is listed for $50,000 on eBay and comes with both a Certificate of Authenticity and the newspaper shot of Hillary Clinton signing the plush in 2006. Ty Beanie Baby 1996 Pouch Kangaroo RARE Tag Errors Mint RED STAR, TY Beanie Baby Hope The Praying Bear 1998 RARE, RARE RETIRED Ty Beanie Baby Paul the Walrus 1999 MINT, rare-1st-edition-princess-diana-1997-retired-beanie, rare-museum-mint-1st-edition-princess-diana-1997-retired-beanie-baby-no-space, ty-beanie-baby-034-curly-034-bear-retired-with-tag-errors-rare, ty-beanie-mystic-unicorn-1994-1993-w-tag-errors-plush-toy-rare-pe-new-retired, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/tag/pinky/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/tag/ariel/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/2017/11/08/ty-beanie-baby-princess-the-diana-bear-from-1997-rare-retired-errors/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/tag/waddle/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/2018/04/19/ty-beanie-baby-snort-bull-1995retired-extremely-rare-4002-all-errors-popular/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/2018/06/18/rare-with-4-errors-vintage-1993-ty-beanie-babies-ivan-stuffed-toy-plush-animal/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/2017/02/09/extremely-rare-ty-beanie-babies-peace-bear-with-all-errors-mistakes-2/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/2019/04/10/maple-the-bear-w-errors-ty-beanie-babies-nib-oakbrook-rare/, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/tag/hissy/, RARE TY Lefty 2000 Beanie Baby With Errors Political Donkey, Mint Ty Beanie Baby Lefty & Righty 2000 Rare, RARE Lefty And Righty Beanie Babies- 1996- TAG ERRORS- PVC Pellets, TY ORIGINAL Lefty The Donkey Beanie Baby IN ORIGINAL PACKAGING Tag Errors Rare, TY Beanie Babies Collection LEFTY 2000 Donkey Rare with Tag Errors, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/tag/lefty/, Featured Refinements: Lefty and Righty 2000 Beanie Baby, Featured Refinements: Ty Princess Beanie Baby, https://tybeaniebabiesrare net/2019/04/19/ty-beanie-babies-collection-lefty-2000-donkey-rare-with-tag-errors/. Claude, the Crab, is incredibly realistic looking and just oozes with cuteness. (Top 15 Highest Selling Beanie Babies) 42 related questions found. BEANIE BABY COLLECTOR CARDS * SERIES 4 - 2ND EDITION * ARTIST PROOF CARDS. Buy & sell Beanie Babies on the #1 Facebook Group, Authenticated Beanie Babies Price GuidePrice guide for authenticated Beanie Babies. 5. . 20 Most Valuable Beanie Babies Worth Money - Noname Antiques Affiliate Disclosure. Did you know? mcdonalds | Rare Beanie Babies remembering account, browser, and regional preferences, remembering privacy and security settings, personalized search, content, and recommendations, helping sellers understand their audience, showing relevant, targeted ads on and off Etsy. . But, all kidding aside, Snort the Red Bull came into being after a name change from Tabasco. Sale Price $72.25 Lefty and Righty Retired Ty Beanie Babies, 2000. Be warned, there are many counterfeit Humphrey Beanie Babies on the market. Waddle Year: 1995 Price: $40,000 Waddle Beanie Baby "China" Rare (Source: eBay) Learn more. Free shipping for many products! Tush Tag is dated 1993 but date of birth is 1997. Peanut the Elephant - $30,000 Peanut the Elephant is one of the rarest of all Beanie Babies, if it's the right color. Have white Beanie with colored stars and 2000 on front mad by Royal Beanie with tag on it. Beanie was created for a MasterCard promotion. From shop BellasBraids $ 20.00. How to Sell Beanie Babies: 9 Steps (with Pictures) - wikiHow Employee the Bear, $3,000 They all just about yellow stars, and its a false statement. Krabs -$20Mr. Hit me up. in, https://www.facebook.com/groups/SellYourBeanieBabies. It additionally fits with both an incandescent halo and angel wings. Lefty and Righty 2000 Beanie Babies StartingOverCo (98) $19.12 $22.50 (15% off) FREE shipping 2000 Retired TY Beanie Babies Lefty & Righty. mcdonalds scoop (unopened) mcdonalds patti (opened) Righty (2000) (USA Exclusive) - Beanie Babies Price Guide Under Add your personalization, the text box will tell you what the seller needs to know. Beanie Babies with Tag Errors Are Not Worth What You Think Made In China. crunch Lefty & Righty-The red, white, and blue animal pair of donkey and elephant known as Righty & Lefty are popular Beanie Babies and were introduced during the 1996 Presidential campaigns. - eBay Money Back Guarantee - opens in a new window or tab, - for PayPal Credit, opens in a new window or tab, Report this item - opens in new window or tab. Love it! 41 Most Valuable Beanie Babies (2022) - Parade: Entertainment, Recipes TY Beanie Babies DESTRA Elefante Repubblicano SINISTRO Asino Probably only $2-$5. Jake the Duck - $600. This 1998 TY rarity did not stay in production for long. During its production change, one significant tag error was the incorrect name being printed on its tag. $12.75, $15.00 GOBBLES THE TURKEY - Common Beanie. Selling Your Beanie Babies Online. 9.7. Peggy Gallagher Enterprises seems to be more esteemed among the appraisers. How much is the coco Presley worth? I have a couple of mistake rares.. does anyone know a collector who will pay top dollar or any leads.. thanks. Ty Beanie Baby: Righty (2000) (US Ex.) (55% off). . Original Price $85.00 The original Peanut the Elephants were created in dark, royal blue in 1995. TY Beanie Baby RARE RIGHTY 2000 the Elephant NO TAGS $199.99 535**, US Vintage Righty The Elephant McDonalds TY American Trio Teenie Beanie Baby 2000 $9.99 510**, US Lefty the Donkey and Righty The Elephant Beanie Babies 2000 w/ Tag Errors $2000.00 115**, US Beanie Babies Mcdonalds 2000 Rex & Righty the Elephant Collectabes SEALED $1.00 770**, US #1 Employee Bear -See Guide#1 Teacher $12 See Guide123s $8 See Guide1997 Holiday Teddy Bear $4 See Guide1998 Holiday Teddy Bear $4 See Guide1999 Holiday Teddy Bear $4 See Guide - Authenticated1999 Signature Bear - $3See Guide2000 Holiday Teddy $4 See Guide - Authenticated2000 Signature Bear $3 See Guide2001 Holiday Teddy $4 See Guide2001 Signature Bear $4 See Guide2002 Holiday Teddy $7 See Guide2002 Signature Bear $4 See Guide2003 Holiday Teddy $4 See Guide2003 Signature Bear $2 See Guide2004 Holiday Teddy $2 See Guide2004 Signature Bear $2 See Guide2005 Holiday Teddy $2 See Guide2005 Signature Bear $5 See Guide2006 Happy New Year Bear $5 See Guide2006 Holiday Teddy $4 See Guide2006 Signature Bear $4 See Guide2006 Zodiac Dog $20 See Guide2007 Happy New Year Bear $4 See Guide2007 Holiday Teddy $5 See Guide2007 Signature Bear $5 See Guide2007 Zodiac Pig $10 See Guide2008 Happy New Year Bear $5 See Guide2008 Zodiac Rat $164-H $5 See Guide, A $4ABC The Bear $4 -See GuideAces $6 - See GuideAddison $3 - See GuideAdmiral $6 - See GuideAdonis $4 - See GuideAdore $5 - See GuideAi $5 - See GuideAlabama $2 - See GuideAlacazam $7 - See GuideAlana $5 - See GuideAlani $3 - See GuideAlberta $4 - See GuideAlex $5 - See GuideAllegro $9 - See GuideAll-Star Dad $5 - See GuideAlly See GuideAlmond $2 - See GuideAlps $3 - See GuideAlvin - See GuideAlways $3 - See GuideAmber $3 - See GuideAmerica - See GuideAmerican $5 - See GuideAmerican Blessing $4 - See GuideAmigo $3 - See Guide, Amore $10 - See GuideAnchor $7 - See GuideAnts $2 - See GuideAotearoa - See GuideApplejack $6 - See GuideApril $6 - See GuideApril Fool $12 - See GuideArabesque $10 - See GuideArctic $8 - See GuideAria $10 - See GuideAriel $4 - See GuideArizona $5 - See GuideArlene $3 - See GuideAruba $3 - See GuideAstra $3 - See GuideAtlanta $5 - See GuideAtlanta Braves $10 - See GuideAugust $5 - See GuideAurora $3 - See GuideAussiebear $4 - See GuideAustin $30 - See GuideAustralia $8 - See GuideAva $10 - See GuideAvalanche $15 - See GuideAvalon $4 - See GuideAware $4 - See GuideAwareness $3 - See GuideAxew $20 - See Guide, B $5B.B. Bear $4 - See GuideBaaabsy $4 - See GuideBaaabsy Baag $10 - See GuideBaabet $7 - See GuideBaboo $6 - See GuideBaby Boy - See GuideBaby Girl - See GuideBaby Jaguar $20 - See GuideBadges $5 - See GuideBadtz-Maru $25 - See GuideBahati $5 - See GuideBaldy $3 - See GuideBali (Lizard) $5Ballerina Peppa $6 - See GuideBaltimore Ravens $6 - See GuideBam $4 - See GuideBananas $5 - See GuideBandage $3 - See GuideBandit $7 - See GuideBandito $3 - See GuideBanjo (2003) $4 - See GuideBanjo (2012) $20 - See GuideBarbaro $12 - See GuideBarklowe $3 - See GuideBarks $10 - See GuideBarley $5 - See GuideBaron Van Pyre $5 - See GuideBasilico $12 - See GuideBAT-e $4 - See GuideBatty (Brown) $3 - See GuideBatty (Tie-Dye) $3 - See GuideBayStars $15 - See GuideBeak $3 - See GuideBeani $5 - See GuideBeanie House Rock $10 - See GuideBeanies! Righty the Elephant - Etsy Its chocolate brown with a Reeses orange bowtie. 20 Rare Beanie Babies With Incredible Value Today - AskMoney.com ringo Does anyone know what this means?
Is there anyone or any where to take them and get an assessment of what I may have? Mystic the Unicorn is an extremely popular beanie baby and was issued in several different editions.
Is that normal? RARE! Excellent - The tag may be creased or worn, but the character itself is still be in perfect condition. So, be sure that Nanas eyes are centered on this cute little monkeys face. Ty beanies Lefty the Donkey & Righty the Elephant, TY BEANIE BABY LEFTY 2000 THE DONKEY RETIRED, TY Beanie Baby - Lefty the Donkey - Stars & Stripes - 4 July - Stocking Filler, American Trio Lefty The Donkey Ty Tennie Original Beanie, Ty Beany Baby 96 American Trio Libearty Bear, Lefty The Donkey, Righty Elephant, TY Beanie Babies BBOC Card - Series 4 Common - LEFTY the Donkey - NM/Mint, 1998 TY Beanie Babies Lefty The Donkey Retired Red & Blue Cards , TY Beanie Babies BBOC Card - Series 1 Retired (RED) - LEFTY the Donkey - NM/Mint, TY Beanie Babies BBOC Card - Series 2 Common - LEFTY the Donkey - NM/Mint, WH Pub. floppity Originally, both signed Beanie Babies held a combined value of $50,000. Princess Diana supporters felt compelled to purchase this beautiful bear at the time as TY sent proceeds to the princesses memorial fund. Send me exclusive offers, unique gift ideas, and personalized tips for shopping and selling on Etsy. 1. The 5 Most Valuable Beanie Babies | Celebrity Net Worth Why you even exist is anybodys guess. Funny enough, one of the unique things about this bear is that kids didnt want anything to do with it; however, collectors would love to have one. Most Beanie Babies are not worth very much money, do not make the mistake of buying a $10 price guide to tell you they aren't worth anything. These Beanie Babies were constructed in two versions: one with PE pellets and one with PVC pellets. The highest listed price on eBay is $14,444, but several are listed at the $1,000 to $4,500 mark. 12 of them are they worth anything. Set the Beanie Baby you're selling on a flat surface in front of a plain backdrop, such as an empty wall. How Much Is Smoochy The Frog Beanie Baby Worth? - Arew While many of the items on Etsy are handmade, youll also find craft supplies, digital items, and more. CLAUD THE CRAB - Claude the Crab isn't worth much more than $2-5. 27 Most Valuable Beanie Babies: Value and Price Guide - Jacqueline Stallone The login page will open in a new tab. Hannah Shinjyuku Mitsukoshi (Ty Store Japan Exclusive) . I mean, who doesnt love a platypus? The History and Evolution of Beanie Babies What are the Most Valuable Beanie Babies? $2-5. Most Beanie Babies are not worth very much money, do not make the mistake of buying a $10 price guide to tell you they aren't worth anything. Beanie Babies are getting thousands of dollars from collectors right now, as much as $50,000 each. Please.
BEANIEBABIESPRICEGUIDE is a participant in Amazon Services LLC, and eBay Inc, Associate Programs that are . The lister usually tells quite a bit about the bear in the description. 6 Lefty The Donkey And Righty The Elephant $50,000. Choose the options youd like for the order.
If you come across a rainbow-maned Mystic, hang on to that Unicorn. All five versions of the Millennium Bear have this elegant and vibrant fuchsia coloration. Nowadays, these plush toys can be worth some big bucks if you are a collector. Discover what errors exist on Beanie Babies and if it impacts the value. Current Price on eBay: $675,000.00. Thank you! While a Hillary signature was surely worth a lot then, we can't imagine how much it would cost now! $393.75, $875.00 Sites like Worthpoint will help you explore the types of beanies sold. They will have certificates and be boxed. Turning off personalized advertising opts you out of these sales. Learn more in our Privacy Policy., Help Center, and Cookies & Similar Technologies Policy. If you have one of these rarer editions, youre sitting on a money pot. This famous Beanie was to represent a guardian angel who would help watch over the kids who kept them snuggled. Beanie Babies with 1st Generation Tush Tags typically are the most valuable! The price list is in alphabetical order. Hippity, Hoppity, and Floppity the Bunnies, $30,000 Valentino the Bear, $42,300 Lefty the Donkey and Righty the Elephant, $50,000 Jolly Walrus, $75,000 Batty, $125,000 Piccadilly Attic, $125,000 Bubbles The price list is in alphabetical order. Several versions of Humphrey exist, including those mainly marketed for McDonalds Happy Meals. Beanie Babies Worth Money. Rare Beanie Babies have RARE tags!Beanie Babies with 1st Generation Tush Tags typically are the most valuable! Original Price $30.00 It Has been stored since the 90s. Lot Of 36 New In Box Kelly Dolls Year 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003 (#253380811069), Better than expected pack very well thank you, Maxwell Hemmens Precision Steam Model Vertical Coal Fired Boiler (#253501246109). . Updated Beanie Babies Price Guide. Its not an old generation but it has a brown nose and black eyes. Today, Humphrey the Camel could fetch you nearly $1,200. the Groom-$5Mr. Use your phone or a camera to take pictures of the Beanie Baby from the front, back, and side. 9.7. (25% off), Sale Price $12.75 (40% off), Sale Price $18,750.00 I have 3 Beanies with cranberry colored tush tags Georgette, Cawley and Bonnie They look to be 3rd generation by their Hang tags, but I cant find them listed in your price guide. Etsy uses cookies and similar technologies to give you a better experience, enabling things like: Detailed information can be found in Etsys Cookies & Similar Technologies Policy and our Privacy Policy. I see hundreds selling for 100 times your listings. BUMP -$10Mr. Lefty, Righty (Your Choice) ad vertisement by BellasBraids. Here's a quick recap of the 20 most expensive beanie babies in the world: Large Wallace and his Squad - $600,000.
This item is in the category "Toys & Hobbies\Beanbag Plush\Ty\Beanie . This commemorative bear was released almost immediately after the tragic death of Princess Diana. Be on the lookout for a Mystic with a fine mane rather than the coarse mane. Righty ERROR: With upside down flag. });
We also created 2.6 million jobs in the U.S.enough to employ the entire city of Houston, TX! These sell for 80% to 90% of the price of the same toy in mint condition. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for TY Beanie Baby - RIGHTY the Elephant , LEFTY the Donkey & Liberty The Bear 1996 at the best online prices at eBay! Even if you have one in perfect condition with no misprints, it could still fetch you over $1,000. Although most sets of Lefty and Righty aren't worth a whole lot, one particular batch that was signed by Hillary Clinton is worth thousands. 14" Large, Ty Teenie Babies Lefty The Donkey Soft Toy Animal with Tag RARE MINT, Lefty the Donkey 2000 McDonalds Ty Beanie Baby - Sealed Package, Ty Beanie Buddy Lefty The Donkey with Tag, Collectable TY Beanie Babies Lefty the USA Donkey 2000 with Tag Stars & Stripes, Ty Beanie Babies Lefty 2000 The Donkey - Mint With Tag Protector, Ty Buddy and Ty Beanie Baby - Lefty the Donkey. 10 Beanie Babies That Seem Valuable, But Are Worth Nothing - TheRichest 11. Definitely, the least valuable Beanie on this list ($20) unless your birthday is in November, then this plush might have some sort of sentimental value for you. Now, if you were to check any reputable Beanie Babies price guide, you would likely find they are worth a small fortune especially for rare figures that have been kept in mint condition and have an accompanying certificate of authenticity. For example. How do I get my Beanies authenticated?